Where Can I Buy Fresh Seafood Online

Share This:

With the closure and reduced seating of most restaurants due to the pandemic, now is a great time to get your seafood fix from the comfort of your own home. So many people will often wonder where I can buy fresh seafood online. I will show the best places currently where to buy safe, fresh, and tasty seafood online.

Eating fresh seafood can sometimes be a problem locally, depending on where you reside in the United States. Often, fish at the local market is questionable at best. Some examples are adding color to salmon and raised seafood. Farm-raised is questionable because oftentimes, they are fed cheap low-grade nutrients and sometimes toxic.

Yeah…questionable seafood for sure. Having seafood in your diet is so important for getting quality nutrients and having tasty meals. This is why I compiled a list of some of the best places to purchase seafood online.

A special note here: all seafood from the companies below is shipped in an insulated box with dry ice, so your seafood products come fresh and frozen.

Vital Choice Wild Seafood & Organics

Vital Choice is just packed full of seafood options all of which are wild-caught and sustainably fished and certified sustainable. Real peace of mind buying from Vital Choice. They offer 15 fresh wild fish options and six fresh shellfish options. This is my personal go-to seafood company.

I have written a couple of articles featuring Vital Choice products that I just love, Vital Choice Salmon Oil Review and Where Can I Buy Wild Caught Alaskan Salmon?

orange vital choice logo

They also have plenty of canned and pouched products to choose from, as well as marine supplements and fair trade, organic & humane premium proteins. They also have a monthly subscription option called Vital Box, which they ship to you in dry ice. They have three boxes to choose from, and they are both highly customizable: Wild Salmon Box, Wild Fish Box, and Wild Seafood Box.

wild king salmon on plate cooked

It’s probably the most well-known and used online seafood company out there. Many celebrities order from here, and it is a great company with many seafood options. I highly recommend this company!

SUBSCRIBE & SIMPLIFY! YeSAVE 5% On Vital Box - Experience The Quality & Purity Of Our Wild Seafood - Delivered Monthly To Your Home All ar Round From Vital Choice & Get Free Shipping On Orders $99+ - Use Code: VCAF5 At Checkout! Shop Now!

Shop seafood at Vital Choice

Fulton Fish Market

This fish market has been open since 1822 and is still going strong today. They pride themselves on offering the largest assortment of fresh seafood in the world. This has the widest selection of seafood on the internet compared to any other online seafood delivery company.

Fulton Fish Market logo

Seafood gets hand-selected every morning for their fresher-than-fresh seafood. Their team of experts and chefs actually do all the hand-selecting of the seafood, so you know you’re in good hands.

You can get 15% off On Your First Order of $150+ With The Code STOCKUP, plus Free two 2-day delivery.

Shop the world's largest assortment of fresh seafood with FREE delivery over $99!

Alaska Gold Seafood

If you are looking for a smaller fishermen-owned co-op based in Alaska that has been around for a long time, you found it in Alaska Gold Seafood. All fish is line-caught, meaning with a rod and fishing line, not by a large net.

alaska gold seafood logo

They are actively selling various wild salmon, halibut, sablefish, albacore tuna, rockfish, and lingcod. They also sell Dungeness crab, canned tuna, and salmon. They offer a seafood variety pack as well as a loyalty program to save money by ordering monthly.

salmon and lettuce on toast

Shop Seafood At Alaska Gold Seafood

Wild Alaskan Company

This is strictly a monthly seafood membership where you pick your plan and the available three choices for the month: Wild Salmon Box, Wild Combo Box (combo of salmon & white fish), or Wild White Fish Box.

black and white wild alaskan company logo

The white fish they offer is Halibut and Cod. The salmon they offer is Sockey and Coho. They are sold either in 12 packs or 24 packs; with the 24 packs, you receive free shipping, which you could save $9.95.

pink salmon on plate

All of the fish that are sold at WAC are wild-caught in Alaska and the Pacific Northwest from sustainably managed fisheries. There are not as many options as some of the other companies on this list, but it is worthy of note just the same.

Shop Seafood At Wild Alaskan Company

Thrive Market

Thrive Market is an online membership grocery store for healthy and natural organic foods, household items, wine, and supplements. They also specialize in diet-specific grocery items for people on popular diets like keto, organic, whole30, paleo, etc.

thrive market logo black

You can read my full review of Thrive Market here. Is Thrive Market A Good Deal? Is It Worth Signing Up?.

Thrive Market has two seafood options within their Meat & Seafood sections. They have a Build Your Own Seafood Box and a “Wild-Caught Sockeye Salmon Box.” There are not as many choices for seafood as the others on this list. You can customize.

The Build Your Own Seafood Box contains various salmon, cod, shrimp, scallops, pollock, crab, tuna, striped bass, and lobster tails. This has a lot of options and is a great way to easily get a variety of seafood in a monthly subscription box.

picture of various seafood cooked

Shop Seafood At Thrive Market

Cameron’s Seafood

This is a Maryland-based company that’s been in business for over 30 years, specializing in 100% authentic Maryland crabs, crab cakes, and crab soups.

transparent cameron's seafood logo

This is the place for buying crabs online but they also have other seafood like shrimp, lobster, shellfish, and a decent amount of fresh fish as well. They claim caught daily, shipped fresh, and delivered to your front door in less than 24 hours.

red crab two cooked

Having over eight varieties of Maryland Blue Crabs and three varieties of crab legs, there are a lot of crab options if that is what you are looking for. They also sell carb meat in sealed plastic containers for easy meals.

Shop Cameron’s Seafood

Lobster Anywhere

Are you looking to get fresh, quality lobster? This is the place, as Lobster Anywhere delivers fresh Maine Lobsters overnight to your door in less than 24 hours, hence the name. As LobsterAnywhere buys hand-selected lobsters from local lobster fishermen and holds them in a live-holding system.

lobster anywhere red logo

They deliver a total of 5 different types of lobster products.

  • Live Lobsters – Lobsters range in size from 1 1/4 pounds up to 6 pounds.
  • Lobster Tails – They have a total of 5 different sizes ranging from medium to Monster Lobster Tails.
  • Lobster Meat
  • Lobster Rolls – Two pounds of premium lobster meat and eight split rolls.
  • Lobster Dinners – Any of the dinners get free shipping.
cooked lobster tail with garnish

They also have fresh shrimp, fresh sea scallops, chowders, bisques, and steaks. If you love lobster, you have to try LA for sure.

Shop Lobster Anywhere


FarmFoods does not sell any farmed fish; they sell only wild-caught fish, and it has to be sustainable, too. FarmFoods has a decent selection of seafood.

  • Alaska Sockeye Salmon
  • Wild Caught Halibut
  • Wild Caught Pacific Cod
  • Wild Caught Shrimp (Alabama Gulf of Mexico)
  • Wild Caught Tuna
  • New Zealand Greenshell Mussels
  • Wild Caught Mahi Mahi
  • Wild Caught Swordfish

FarmFoods Logo -

Saving Money on Seafood Online

My first tip for saving money online in general, and this can be applied to most of the companies above, is installing Honey, either on your smartphone or an extension on your browser for home computers. This simple app/extension automatically checks for coupon codes and applies them at checkout, and you do nothing. It’s that easy.

The second way to save on seafood online is to save on shipping costs. Most of the companies will have free shipping if you go over a certain price range.

Seafood Is Amazing

We all should be enjoying more wild-caught seafood as it provides healthy benefits and keeps our meals interesting.

Any thoughts or comments are appreciated, and I will try to respond as fast as I can. Thanks!

Share This:

2 thoughts on “Where Can I Buy Fresh Seafood Online”

  1. Thanks for the awesome post, Dan! I didn’t even know you can buy fresh seafood online. I live in a landlocked area so most of the seafood I eat is either frozen or from a farm. Being able to buy fresh seafood online opens a ton of food options for me which is great because I love seafood. I do live in Canada, though. Do you know if these companies ship to Canada?

    • Yes, they all ship to Canada so a great option for Canadians too. I too am landlocked and by days of land in between me and the open ocean. This wasn’t always the case as I used to live an hour from the pacific ocean and easily obtain fresh seafood with little to no problem. So, having a delivery method for me was of utmost importance, hope this article helps you find some great seafood. Let me know how it goes would love to hear how your experience turned out. 

Leave a Comment